The snobbery is very precise: you have to go to Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Stanford and, perhaps, Wharton. And the reason for this is not the belief that these schools provide the best education—in fact, many of those evaluating job candidates were critical of the education offered by these schools. Rather, it seems that the elite firms are simply using getting into Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Standford and Wharton as a proxy for intelligence.
All in all, the study makes sense from my point of view. And the fundamental critique: why trust college admissions offices to make your decisions for you also makes sense. This is just an easy, low risk way to find bright, hard working talent that won't embarrass you. But it's not particularly egalitarian in its conception.
Hat tip instapundit
No comments:
Post a Comment