Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Is the long progressive nightmare coming to and end?

The Progressive movement was founded on the belief that the state could manipulate people's lives and choices to make them better.  Its greatest policy 'triumph' was alcohol prohibition - the assertion that the State could manage the private behavior of hundreds of millions.  Forced by disaster to quit that 'triumph', the progressive dreams of manipulating individual behavior stayed alive with ever more draconian punishments targeted at less 'popular' drugs, savaging tens of millions of lives for in effect committing 'crimes against the state'.  Now there is evidence that the nation is slowly waking up from its long progressive nightmare.  For the first time in history more people support legalizing Marijuana than oppose it.  I think this tracks the general disillusionment with the ability of the state to manipulate humans (except to gather rents for it's supporters).  If so, it is a wonderful portent.

Of liberty.  Faster, please.



Canadian columnist Neil Reynolds writing in the Globe and Mail:

"The American war on drugs – or, more generically, the global war on drugs – can’t be won. The more intensely that governments wage it, the more certain is the defeat. This is because risk determines reward. More pressure on the supply of drugs means more risk and more profits. More profits mean more drugs and more violence. The proof is in the body count across Mexico, across Central and South America and, indeed, across the Western Hemisphere."


"Ironically, drugs became a significant problem only when governments declared war on them. Although Richard Nixon cited drugs as “public enemy No. 1” when he declared war in 1971, the statistical evidence doesn’t support the pronouncement. The U.S. incarceration rate, now the highest in the world, was one-eighth the problem 40 years ago than it is now. From 1920 through 1970, the rate remained flat: with 0.1 per cent of Americans in prison at any one time. By 1980, the rate doubled: 0.2 per cent. By 1990, it doubled again: 0.5 per cent. By 2010, it reached a record high: 0.8 per cent. This exceeds two million people – roughly 25 per cent of whom are serving time for drugs."

"The consequences of the war on drugs are appalling, from excruciating personal suffering to intractable national tragedy. It’s enough to note that the death toll in Mexico alone exceeded 15,000 last year, bringing the number of people killed in the past five years to nearly 40,000."

"Harvard economist Jeffrey Miron, incidentally, says legalizing drugs would save the United States $44-billion a year in law-enforcement costs and generate another $42-billion in tax revenue – finally, after the longest war in American history, a peace dividend that could buy a lot of help for a lot of troubled people."

Related: Support for legalization of marijuana in the U.S. is at an all-time historical high based on a new Gallup poll (see chart above), and according to CBS News: "If the steady climb in public support for marijuana legalization continues at its current pace, politicians will soon have to address the laws that fly in the face of that movement in opinion."

No comments:

Post a Comment